Mastando & Artrip LLC

(256) 532-2222 or (800) 434-7195

  • About
    • News
  • Attorneys
    • Eric Artrip
    • Tony Mastando
    • Teri Mastando
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury
      • Car Accidents
      • Nursing Home Litigation
      • Motorcycle Accidents
      • Slip and Fall
      • Truck Accidents
      • Wrongful Death
    • Workplace Litigation
      • Whistleblower Rewards and Protection
      • Employment Law
        • Unfair Compensation & Unpaid Wages
      • Commercial Litigation
      • Business Contracts
      • Media Law
      • Government Contracting
    • Complex Litigation
    • Class Action
    • Real Estate
  • Blog
  • Testimonials
  • Contact Us
Home » Whistle Blower Law » Whistleblower Tells of Billion Dollar Medicare Fraud: Incentive to Defraud?

June 20, 2017 By Tony Mastando

Whistleblower Tells of Billion Dollar Medicare Fraud: Incentive to Defraud?

false claims act whistleNYT article: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/15/business/dealbook/a-whistle-blower-tells-of-health-insurers-bilking-medicare.html
Before we can talk about Benjamin Poehling, the whistleblower claiming UnitedHealth Group and others have been systematically scamming Medicare for years, we need to talk about a program called Medicare Advantage.

Medicare Advantage was created in 2003 as a way to fix the budget crisis Medicare faced. This program gave part of Medicare over to private insurance companies, with the expectation that those insured could receive better care for less money. Now, a third of Americans receiving Medicare do so under Medicare Advantage. Previously, the private insurers would take on these patients and then submit claims to the government for reimbursement of the money spent on the patients in the form of procedures. However, this provided an incentive for doctors to perform unnecessary procedures, raising the overall cost of the program and wasting taxpayer money. So, Medicare Advantage was set up differently.

Under Medicare Advantage, a private insurer is paid a set yearly fee for each patient it takes on that is covered by the program. This fee is determined not by procedures performed, but by diagnoses. This fee is affected most by a patient being treated recently for certain conditions, which provides incentive for insurers to go looking for diagnoses. The example given in the NYT article is that of a patient diagnosed with diabetes and kidney failure when she was taken on, but if the insurer could argue that the kidney failure had been caused by diabetes, the insurer would receive an additional $3,300 a year for that patient.

That’s where Mr. Poehling and other whistleblowers like him come in. Poehling worked for UnitedHealth for ten years, from 2002 to 2012, as a finance director. Poehling claims that UnitedHealth was abusing government funds through Medicare Advantage by only searching for diagnoses that would raise a patient’s “risk score,” or the measurement of a patient’s health that determines how much an insurer is paid for that patient. Poehling says that in the example of the patient with diabetes, UnitedHealth would not also screen for high blood pressure, a potentially dangerous condition, because high blood pressure would not raise the patient’s risk score. Poehling also says that he and his coworkers were given bonuses for achieving revenue targets, but not for “better health outcomes or for more accurate patients’ charts.”

Poehling is suing UnitedHealth under the False Claims Act for the potentially billions of dollars the company may have received from the government under false pretenses. Whistleblowers, people like Poehling, who come forward with information about potential misuse of taxpayer funds, are protected under the FCA. They seek to bring these companies to justice, and are rewarded with a percentage of whatever payout results from the case.

Even well-intended programs designed to thwart one type of fraud can create unintended incentives for other types of fraud. Companies and individuals who cannot resist the temptation to skirt the rules and claim benefits to which they are not entitled are setting themselves up for prosecution. Oftentimes employee-insiders figure out or know about the fraud, are uncomfortable with what they’re being asked to do on the job, and make the difficult decision to put a stop to it.

Mastando & Artrip are experienced in handling cases like these where whistleblowers seek to bring to light misdeeds by private companies. If you believe you may have information about a FCA violation, give us a call at 256-532-2222 and we’ll be happy to speak to you.

Filed Under: Whistle Blower Law

About Tony Mastando

Tony Mastando is a partner at Mastando & Artrip. Mr. Mastando received his Juris Doctorate from the University of Michigan Law School and a Bachelor of Science from the University of Florida. He was elected to Phi Beta Kappa and Golden Key National Honor Societies.

Practice Areas

  • Personal Injury
    • Car Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Nursing Home Litigation
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Slip and Fall
    • Truck Accidents
    • Wrongful Death
  • Workplace Litigation
    • Whistleblower Rewards and Protection
    • Employment Law
      • Unfair Compensation & Unpaid Wages
    • Commercial Litigation
    • Business Contracts
    • Media Law
    • Government Contracting
  • Complex Litigation
  • Class Action
  • Real Estate

Featured Posts

  • Whistleblowers & the False Claims Act
  • What to Do After an Accident
  • Protecting Our Girls In Schools
Defending Your Rights

Need Legal Help? Get in touch.

Serving North Alabama from Huntsville

  • (###) ###-####

Recent Posts

  • Judge Slashes Some of Fiat Chrysler, Cummins Truck Engine Defect Suit
  • A Discussion with Employment Attorney Teri Mastando
  • Google Accused Of Raking In $1B From Unauthorized Ads
  • Customers Call Bunk On AT&T’s New Docs In Throttle Suit
  • News After being beaten while handcuffed, two inmates sue Alabama prison guards

What Our Clients Say

A few years ago, a driver pulled out in front of me while I was on my motorcycle. Eric and Tony were relentless in dealing with the insurance company. Highly recommended lawyers. - Jim Curry, Ph.D.

Article Categories

  • Car Accidents
  • Class Action Lawsuits
  • Employment Law
  • Government Contracts
  • Huntsville
  • Law
  • Motorcycle Law
  • News
  • Personal Injury
  • Real Estate
  • Sexual Harassment
  • Whistle Blower Law
class=

Contact Us for Help

  • Motorcycle Accidents
  • Truck Accidents
  • Hill v Madison Co Timeline

Huntsville’s Small Business and Personal Legal Service Team

Our law firm practices in Huntsville, Decatur, Athens and Northern Alabama areas within the Madison County and nearby court jurisdictions.

Conveniently Located in Downtown Huntsville

Mastando & Artrip LLC

301 Washington St NW #302
Huntsville, AL 35801

Phone: (256) 532-2222
Toll free: (800) 434-7195

View a Map to our Office

Copyright © 2021 Mastando & Artrip, LLC. All rights reserved · Privacy Policy · Website by 2theTop Web Design

  • About
    • News
  • Attorneys
    • Eric Artrip
    • Tony Mastando
    • Teri Mastando
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury
      • Car Accidents
      • Nursing Home Litigation
      • Motorcycle Accidents
      • Slip and Fall
      • Truck Accidents
      • Wrongful Death
    • Workplace Litigation
      • Whistleblower Rewards and Protection
      • Employment Law
        • Unfair Compensation & Unpaid Wages
      • Commercial Litigation
      • Business Contracts
      • Media Law
      • Government Contracting
    • Complex Litigation
    • Class Action
    • Real Estate
  • Blog
  • Testimonials
  • Contact Us